Order Online

The Slow Roll


We’re pleased to announce our partnering with Superior Dishes to accommodate our shipping needs. While we’re still doing the work on our end (receiving the order, packing the pies, etc.) Superior Dishes uses  their aggressive shipping rates which will allow us to get the pies to you with a little savings on the overnight shipping.

Please note: Superior Dishes notes a 3~12-day ship time, which has caused some confusion. We ship every Tuesday and Wednesday. 

Our 10-inch key lime pie.

Before you head to their ordering page, we want to preface things with a heads-up. The prices listed on Superior Dishes include all overnight shipping, packaging materials and pesky extra costs. By far, the shipping is the bulk of the costs, and in the end, their costs are below what we were able to negotiate with all of the shippers. Please keep this in mind, and we’ve even taken a cut from our profits to partner with Superior Dishes in order to bring these savings to you.

All that being said, head on over and have a look. Once you’re done, please contact us regarding the experience, we’re interested in getting some feedback.

We highly suggest that you sign-up for our mailing list  so when all those hidden-gears are meshed and operating as planned, you’ll get the heads-up. We also suggest following (or “liking?”) our Facebook  page.

Steve and Team Keylime.




Want Pie?2022 Summer Storefront Hours

For shipping inquiries, please follow this link to read about our partners at Superior Dishes. We do not offer local deliveries with the exception of our commercial customers, sorry.

Our hours for our local Red Hook/NYC customers. We're open and have plenty of pies available at our storefront.

  • Monday~Thursday 12~7 PM
  • Friday, 12 ~8 PM
  • Saturday 11 AM~8 PM
  • Sunday 11 AM~7 PM

Be sure and enter your email address below in order to get on our mailing list when we prepare our next shipping date. Thank you again.