Pies and Tarts

Our classic 10-inch authentic key lime pie.

This is where it all started, and this is where it remains today, but even better. Our classic 10-inch key lime pie is made in a hand-formed crust using nothing more than pure butter and our proprietary recipe of house-baked Graham cracker crumbs. As always, 100% pure, fresh squeezed key lime juice. A favorite with our food service customers and for larger gatherings. Typically serves eight.

Same Great Pie, Smaller Portion.

Not up for a 10-inch pie? Easier on the wallet and the waistline, our family-friendly eight-inch pie might be the right choice for you. Made to the same exacting standards as all of our pies. A favorite of our resellers (check availability) and always available at our  Red Hook location.

Perfect for a party of one.

Our single-serve four-inch tart is just enough to satisfy, one mouth at a time. Whether for yourself to share with a loved one or for a special occasion for a thousand, these little gems are sure to satisfy. Always fresh and always available at our Red Hook location and some of our retailers (check for availability.) A big favorite for banquets, weddings, and special events. It’s your affair; serve what you want. For large orders, please contact our sales staff via our contact page.

The Teaser.

We also offer an even smaller version,  “The Teaser,” which is a three-inch mini-tart that goes well on a tasting table or where multiple desserts are being served.  Also available as party favors individually boxed with a variety of options. Please see our wholesale page (coming) for more information. Event planners and corporate customers love these.


Want Pie?SPRING Storefront Hours

For shipping inquiries, see the button below. We do not offer local deliveries except for our commercial customers, sorry.

Our hours for our local Red Hook/NYC customers. We're open and have plenty of pies available at our storefront.

  • Monday~Thursday 12~6 PM
  • Friday, 12 ~7 PM
  • Saturday 11 AM~7 PM
  • Sunday 11 AM~6 PM

Please note the above is our minimum open hours of storefront operation; we're often here later than the posted hours, but you're taking the chance. No guarantees. 

Be sure and enter your email address below to get on our seldom-used mailing list. Thank you again.